When the Harvest Drowns Zainab Iftikhar

In the vast tapestry of Pakistan’s diverse landscapes, another issue unfolds – the unfortunate journey from food scarcity to food insecurity. While the country boasts a rich agricultural heritage, it grapples with multifaced social, political, economic, and environmental challenges that threaten its food security. The latter, in the form of floods, is one challenge the country is facing even as this article is read, and rains lash various regions.

In the not so distant past – during the summer of 2022 – Pakistan experienced a catastrophic event that shook the nation to its core –  devastating floods that wreaked havoc across vast regions of the country. Triggered by heavy monsoon rains exacerbated by climate change, these floods unleashed a relentless force of destruction leaving a trail of loss and shattered communities in their wake. The impact on the agricultural sector was particularly severe. The floods damaged 80 to 90% of crops across the country. According to a report, 3.6 million acres of crops were destroyed and 800,000 livestock perished. The loss of agricultural productivity affected farmers’ livelihoods and had wider implications for the nation’s food supply chain. This resultantly shot inflation even higher, which was already on the rise after the COVID-19 Pandemic. According to certain reports, Pakistan’s inflation rate was over 24% prior to the floods, and certain commodity prices increased by 500%

Poor governance, vested interests, and delayed response added to the devastation. Timely and accurate responses to early warning systems are crucial in enabling communities to evacuate and take necessary precautions. However, despite repeated early warnings issued by the Pakistan Meteorological Department, relevant authorities were slow in taking preemptive steps. Although the floods started mid-June 2022, establishment of a new National Flood Response and Coordination Centre was not announced till the end of August. Insufficient investment in flood protection infrastructure, including embankments, flood channels, and drainage systems, also contributed to the severity of flood impacts. Aging and poorly constructed water infrastructure was also unable to withstand the force of the waters, leading to breaches and widespread inundation. Unplanned urbanisation, encroachment on floodplains, and illegal construction along riverbanks have obstructed natural water flow channels, exacerbating the intensity and extent of flooding. Additionally, since political parties and factions are deeply divided and prioritise their own agendas over collective welfare, the process of effectively addressing and mitigating flood risks has become challenging and, consequently, there is lack of a unified and cohesive approach to flood management. For instance, last year, Chief Ministers belonging to opposition parties did not attend the National Flood Emergency meeting called by the government, chaired by the Prime Minister himself.

According to a recent Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) report, Pakistan is one of 20 nations vulnerable to excessive rainfall as a result of climate change. Hence, this is one environmental calamity which will continue to loom. Moreover, the rising inflow of water into our rivers from India which is often unannounced, continues to endanger villages banks raising the possibility of flood-like situation in Chenab, Ravi and Sutlej. The situation is already alarming as 95 people, stranded near Ravi and Tawi were recovered as water level in the rivers surged to a perilous level in July 2023.  

Additionally, 29% of the population is facing acute food insecurity between April to October 2023 and the situation is likely to worsen between November 2023 to January 2024. Similarly, a United Nations report has designated Pakistan as a ‘very high concern area’ in terms of food insecurity. 

In light of the above-mentioned facts, the silent hunger gripping Pakistan demands coordinated action, where federal and provincial policies are in sync with community empowerment, where innovation meets tradition, and compassion drives human security. 

To cope with the alarming issue, investment in agricultural research and development should be prioritised to promote sustainable farming practices, improve irrigation systems, and provide farmers with access to modern technologies. Authorities should develop and implement climate change adaptation strategies that focus on building resilience in the agricultural sector. This includes promoting drought-resistant crop varieties, improving water management systems, and implementing and responding to early warning systems to mitigate the impact of climate-related disasters. Enhancing water management practices through investments in irrigation infrastructure, rainwater harvesting, and water conservation techniques should be accorded the highest priority. Conditional cash transfers and targeted food assistance to provide immediate relief and support to the vulnerable population in accessing nutritious food can help strengthen social safety nets. 

Most importantly, it is crucial for political leaders to prioritise the greater good and work together because the fight against food insecurity, brought on by severe monsoon floods, requires not just a full plate, but a full-hearted commitment to putting aside petty politics, empowering communities, embracing sustainability, and dismantling the grounds that perpetuate hunger. 

Zainab Iftikhar is a Research Assistant at the Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS), Islamabad, Pakistan. She can be reached at [email protected]

Design Credit: Mysha Dua Salman


Share this article

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Recent Publications

Browse through the list of recent publications.

The Cover-up: IAF Narrative of the May 2025 Air Battle

Even after one year since the India-Pakistan May war of 2025, the Indian discourse regarding Operation Sindoor remains uncertain under its pretence of restraint. The Pahalgam attack on 22 April, which killed 26 people, triggered an escalatory spiral. New Delhi quickly accused Pakistan-linked elements, while Islamabad refuted the allegation and demanded an independent investigation. On 7 May, India launched attacks deep inside Pakistan under what it later termed as Operation Sindoor. The political motive was intended to turn the crisis into coercive signalling by shifting the blame onto the enemy and projecting a sense of military superiority.
This episode, however, began to fray immediately as war seldom follows the intended script. Within minutes PAF shot down 7 IAF aircraft including 4 Rafales. On 8 May, Reuters reported that at least two Indian aircraft were shot down by a Pakistani J-10C, while the local government sources reported other aircraft crashes in Indian-occupied Jammu and Kashmir

Read More »

Why the IAF’s Post-Sindoor Spending Surge is a Sign of Panic

After Operation Sindoor, India is spending billions of dollars on new weapons. This is being taken by many people as an indication of military prowess. It is not. This rush to procure weapons is in fact an acknowledgement that the Air Force in India had failed to do what it was meant to do. The costly jets and missiles that India had purchased over the years failed to yield the promised results.

Sindoor was soon followed by India in sealing the gaps which the operation had exposed. It was reported that Indian Air Force (IAF) is looking to speed up its purchases of more than 7 billion USD. This will involve other Rafale fighter jets with India already ordering 26 more Rafales to the Navy in 2024 at an estimated cost of about 3.9 billion USD. India is also seeking long-range standoff missiles, Israeli loitering munitions and increased drone capabilities. Special financial powers of the Indian military were activated to issue emergency procurement orders. The magnitude and rate of these purchases speak volumes.

Indian media and defence analysts have over the years considered the Rafale as a game changer. When India purchased 36 Rafales aircrafts at an approximate cost of 8.7 billion USD, analysts vowed that the aircraft would provide India with air superiority over Pakistan. Operation Sindoor disproved all those allegations. Indian aircraft did not even fly in Pakistani airspace when the fighting started. India solely depended on standoff weapons that were launched at a safe distance. The air defence system of Pakistan, comprising of the HQ-9 surface-to-air missile system and its own fighters, stood its ground.

Read More »

May 2025: Mosaic Warfare and the Myth of Centralised Air Power

Visualise a modern-day Air Force commander sitting in the operations room, miles away from the combat zone, overseeing every friendly and enemy aircraft and all assets involved in the campaign. In a split second, he can task a fighter, reposition a drone, and authorise a strike. In today’s promising technological era, he does not even need an operations room; a laptop on his desktop will suffice. The situation looks promising as it offers efficiency, precision, and control. The term used for such operational control is ‘centralisation’, which has been made possible with advanced networking, integrating space, cyber, surveillance, artificial intelligence, and seamless communication, enabling a single commander to manage an entire campaign from a single node. Centralised command and control, championed by the Western air forces and then adopted by many others, has thus been seen as a pinnacle of modern military power.
The concept of centralisation, enabled by state-of-the-art networking, may seem promising, but it is nothing more than a myth.

Read More »