Pinata - Dr Usman- Article thematic Image - January 2023 copy 2

Share this article

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

For centuries, the children of Mexico have played with a candy-filled toy at birthday parties known as a piñata. The piñata is a large, animal-shaped stuffed toy that is hung from trees, with the idea that children will pick up large sticks and beat the piñata to a pulp, letting all the sweets pop out from inside. Parents enjoy using piñatas to distract children, letting the kids focus their violent energies on the stuffed toy and keep the childrens’ mob-energies at bay during the party.

It is with the same Mexican fiesta mindset that the political chatter now raises the specter of a “technocratic government,” which is to come in (unelected), and take all the “hard decisions” that need to be taken, so that the current setup does not need to take any electoral blowback or public backlash for those tough policy choices. In other words, the current setup would, like Mexican parents at a fiesta, put up the technocratic regime as a large, pink piñata. The public would pick up their sticks, like kids at a fiesta, and bash the piñata for all of the economic hardships it would face. The politicians would, in such a situation, watch gleefully as the so-called “technocrats” are strung up by the mob while attempting to force-feed the public any bitter pills of unpopular reforms.

This is not a reasonable way to manage a society, and the premise of so-called “technocrat” piñatas suffers from two basic flaws. The first is that technocratic governments do not have a sufficiently strong record of performance over the past 75 years. Their reforms are piecemeal at best, and serve a multitude of interests other than the people of Pakistan themselves. There are ideological and perceptual limitations in their actions, which are a subject of the places where they have been trained, and whose tagline they follow. Although the word “technocrat” sounds like some progressive, futuristic techno-buzz, Pakistan’s technocrats are often old enough to have seen Noah’s ark in action, and their (sometimes octogenarian) advanced age reflects outmoded “technocracy.”As such, there is little solace in the word “technocrat” as we approach the second quarter of the 21st century, while these old goofs of IMF props were witness to 2100 B.C. and have come time and time again under various governments with little to show for it.

The second problem is that, like the Mexican fiesta-parents who want the kids distracted, the politicians want to keep the public’s ire off their backs. This scapegoating is both silly and undemocratic. If politicians cannot take hard decisions and see them to implementation in the national interest, then they aren’t “leaders” worthy of the name. In that case, they simply shouldn’t lead. Good leadership requires mobilizing the people towards common goals and persuading them to sacrifice in the immediate term for a greater good. In the Art of War, this is the first of the traits mentioned in the evaluation of the leader: the Moral Law. If politicians cannot muster such leadership, and intend to put gerontocratic stuffed-animals at the helm, then why should they vie for power?

The solution, therefore, is not to place piñatas to begin with. A government that reflects the will of the people must come and serve. By the people, for the people, and persuade the public that difficult choices, if taken, will help the nation to weather the difficult international storm that the world is passing through. Let the organizers at the fiesta know: the case for gerontocrats and kleptocrats are both weak; but the case for democracy, supported by technical expertise and the will of the people, is strong.

Dr. Usman W. Chohan is the Director for Economic Affairs and National Development at the Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS), Islamabad, Pakistan. He can be reached at dir.econ@casstt.com.

Recent Publications

Browse through the list of recent publications.

18th Lok Sabha Polls: Islamophobia and Electoral Partisanship

The Indian political horizon is in a frenzy with the ongoing 18th Lok Sabha polls. Voting for the multi-phase elections started on 19th April  and will span over six weeks, with results scheduled to be announced on 4th June. This election is primarily between the two main alliances: Narendra Modi’s BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) and Congress-led 28-party opposition alliance, Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance (INDIA).

13 views

Read More »

East or West? Who Will Rule the 5th Industrial Revolution?  

The world economy saw a ‘great divergence’ as a result of the first two Industrial Revolutions (IR-1 and IR-2) between 1750 and 1950 AD. The economic shift occurred from East to West as a result of industrial development by Western European nations led by Great Britain. The key to their success was the use of then-new technologies like steam power, mechanisation, automobiles, railways, telegraphs or electricity at every level of industrialisation

34 views

Read More »

Indigenisation of Drones: A Security Imperative for Pakistan

For any state, it is of paramount importance how it guarantees national security. This can be ensured through the use or threat of use of force and also mobilising its defence sector in times of conflict and war. In other words, it revolves around the defence capabilities that allow a state to carry out fundamental functions including ‘preventing, deterring, coercing and countering national security threats’.

70 views

Read More »

Stay Connected

Follow and Subscribe

Join Our Newsletter
And get notified everytime we publish new content.

© 2022 CASSTT ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Developed By Team CASSTT

Contact CASS

CASS (Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies), Old Airport Road, Islamabad
+92 51 5405011
cass.thinkers@casstt.com
career@casstt.com

All views and opinions expressed or implied are those of the authors/speakers/internal and external scholars and should not be construed as carrying the official sanction of CASS.