Unchecked India: A Threat to Peace
Author Name: Hasaan Tahir 08 Feb 2021 India

The ambitions of India’s military modernization are growing at odds with her ally - United States’ 2017 law aimed at deterring nations from procuring Russian military hardware. The recent friction between two strategic partners surfaced on Russian origin S-400 Surface-to-Air missile system, which New Delhi is keen to fully commission by 2022, whereas, Washington is persistently telling the Indians to drop the $5.5 billion deal of five systems and avoid an inter-state diplomatic crisis.
The Trump Administration had imposed sanctions on Turkey last month for its acquisition of the same Russian air defence system under the stipulations of Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA), and warned of similar consequences for India. However, New Delhi is resolutely advancing towards acquiring the defence shield without paying heed to any opposition, and even made an initial payment of $800 million in 2019 to initiate delivery. The first set of missile batteries are expected to reach India towards the end of this year. India’s undeterred attitude toward military modernization fundamentally reflects several multifarious objectives.
First, New Delhi has adhered to a policy of ‘non-alignment’ in the past and is still attempting to maintain the same neutrality, which its policy cadre generally propagates as ‘strategic autonomy’. Nonetheless, the incumbent BJP Government, under the leadership of Narendra Modi, appears to be oscillating owing to the unfolding geo-political contestation in the Indo-Pacific region between China and the United States.
Second, Indian security manoeuvres come in the backdrop of its security sensitivities vis-à-vis her neighbour China. Both nations have fought one full-fledged war in 1962, followed by various skirmishes of which, the recent stand-off in June last year was the bloodiest one, resulting in casualties on both sides.
By acquiring the S-400 system, Indian planners hope to shield their major cities and sensitive installations from any incoming Chinese missile. They believe that after acquiring the full strength of Rafale Fighters, coupled with the S-400 defence system, the country might have more power parity with China, at least to the level of strategic equilibrium.
Third, New Delhi has hegemonic designs at least within the South Asian Region, which were substantially manifested at the time of the Uri attack in 2016, followed by the Pulwama incident on 26 February, 2019. Both times, India showcased her belligerence by claiming surgical strikes in the border and settled areas of Pakistan in the guise of targeting terrorist hideouts.
Pakistan, on the other hand, should not be considered a pliant state to take such blatant, illegal actions lying down. This was effectively demonstrated on 27 February, 2019 in response to India through six non-military retaliatory aerial strikes inside Indian Illegally Occupied Kashmir.
Albeit China, Russia and US played their respective roles in reducing tensions between the two South Asian arch-rivals, but India’s irresponsible state policies pushed the region to the brink of war.
During Narendra Modi’s years in government since 2014, a general impression has prevailed that India is leaning toward Washington’s camp to curtail China’s expanding wings. However, the current diplomatic divergence over S-400 seems to be an attempt to dispel that impression. In response to Washington’s warnings, New Delhi has reiterated that “India has always pursued an independent foreign policy. This also applies to our defence acquisitions and supplies which are guided by our national security interests.” The statement signals to the Biden administration India’s future position - whenever a situation demands, New Delhi will choose any side.
One thing is evident, India, by staying away from Sino-US rivalry, is diversifying her options to fulfil her defence appetite. Presently, Indian military needs are being met by France, Israel, Russia and United States. But, the Indian policy of ‘strategic autonomy’ poses greater risks to South Asian strategic stability, particularly during the present BJP regime. An unchecked India, under a Hindu nationalist government, can commit any misadventure that can drag the region’s security situation out of control.
Hasaan Tahir is a researcher at the Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS). He can be contacted at: cass.thinkers@gmail.com.

Recent Articles
- Hindutva: BJP’s Anti–Secular Agenda Read more
- PAF and its Modus Operandi Read more
- The Missile Incident and Indian Misinformation Read more
- Indo-US Partnership: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Saffron Terror: India’s Approach towards Minorities Read more
- India’s Radioactive Bazaar Read more
- Was it Really an Accident? Read more
- Hindu Rashtra: From RSS to BJP Read more
- Ukraine Crisis: India Walking a Tightrope between Kremlin and Washington Read more
- Fascism in India and Silence of the American Government Read more
- Will India contain China? Lessons for the US Read more
- Eroding Indian Democracy Read more
- Military Alliances versus Economic Cooperation Read more
- Regional Implications of BECA between US and India Read more
- Indian Festivities over the S-400 Air Defense System Read more
- The Plight of Indian Muslims: On and Off the Pitch Read more
- The Honour for the Dishonoured Read more
- Unfolding Crisis Involving India’s Nuclear Program Read more
- The Rise and Fall of Indian Secularism Read more
- Rivalries in the Indian Armed Forces Read more
- India’s Dangerous Designs Read more
- Indian Military Procurements: A Scandalous Affair Read more
- Cocktail of Islamophobia and Misogyny in India Read more
- The Sick Man of Asia Read more
- On Trade with India Read more
- All Hands Count Read more
- Strategy of Stage Management Read more
- The S-400 Deal: Will India be able to Balance Relations with Russia and the US? Read more
- Indian Military Modernisation: Response Options for Pakistan Air Force Read more
- COVID-19 Lessons from our Neighbor Read more
- BJP Rule and its Impact on Indian Society Read more
- Modi’s Peace Overture: Genuine or a Trojan Horse? Read more
- What Our Elders Knew Read more
- India’s Balakot Strike: An Analysis Read more
- Unchecked India: A Threat to Peace Read more
- Protesting Farmers and the Indian Agrarian System Read more
- The Hindutva Rate of Growth Read more
- Why the S 400 would not Serve India’s Purpose? Read more
- The Abettors of Rage Read more
- India’s Military Modernization: A Risk to Strategic Equilibrium Read more
- India – A Restless Revisionist State Read more
- Unfolding the Indian Strategy Read more
- Standoff in the Himalayas Read more
- India Falters Amidst the Pandemic Read more
- Coronavirus May Have Exposed India’s Economic Fault Lines Read more
- Towards “The End of India”! Read more
- Pulwama attack: What Compelled Modi to Employ the Air Option? Read more
- The Decade of Dying Secularism in India Read more
- India's Rising Majoritarianism Read more
- India-Pakistan Crises and Nuclear Escalation Dynamics Read more
- Reviewing the Brotherhood in Saffron Read more
- The Underlying Political Deception of BJP in India Read more
- The Myth of Indian Democracy Read more
- Pakistan's response compulsion to India Read more
- Pulwama aftermath; Call to sanity Read more