The Need for Productive Engagement with New Afghan Government
Author Name: Dr Zia Ul Haque Shamsi 08 Sep 2021

“Politics is the art of the possible.” Bismarck’s (1815-1898) precepts about the possibilities in the political arena are widely quoted, and followed by political scientists. His dicta have withstood extremely challenging, and evolving international scenarios. On the other hand, Lord Palmerston’s brilliant concept that “there are no permanent friends, and foes in the international relations,” laid the foundations for unending diplomatic manoeuvres in international affairs.
Diplomatic phrases like constructive engagement, cooperative engagement, détente, rapprochement, confrontation, denial, pain and punishment and preventive or pre-emption all reflect a state’s intended strategies towards other states. States believe that these policy phrases or slogans carry the administration’s image, and would be long remembered whether they achieve the intended purpose or not. However, one needs to look deep into these phrases to find out how much of politics is embedded in these statements. For instance, in the context of India-Pakistan relations, the popular phrase of “Composite Dialogue” is the centrepiece of conflict management mechanism between the nuclear neighbours, having a long history of wars and conflicts. The costs and benefits of its agenda items are debatable, but it is the outcome that one is interested in, after years and years of interaction under this banner. If one understands fully how India-Pakistan relations are overly complex, it becomes clear that the issues involved cannot be easily resolved in the existing environment.
Historically, each war and conflict is followed by a peace treaty or an agreement, and there have been many such agreements between extremely hostile nations. World War-I resulted in the signing of the Treaty of Versailles on June 28, 1919, whereas several treaties were signed under the Paris Peace Treaties, on February 10, 1947, after the end of World War II.
The Afghan wars are no exception. The Geneva Accords signed on April 14, 1988, between Afghanistan and Pakistan, and guaranteed by the US and the USSR, formally ended the First Afghan War of recent history, thus ending the nearly nine-year-long Soviet’s occupation of Afghanistan. The situation is no different after over three decades because Doha Agreement signed on February 29, 2020, ends a 20-year long US occupation of Afghanistan.
While the international community in general, and stakeholders in particular, are still grappling with the fast-evolving situation in Afghanistan with unknown consequences of the incoming Taliban government in Kabul, this article is aimed at urging states to engage the new Afghan government under the paradigm of “Productive Engagement.” The Policy of Productive Engagement calls for a sincere, and dedicated effort to benefit from each other’s experiences and expertise, and converting relationships for mutually productive outcomes, instead of mere photo sessions of the summit meetings. Realists would argue that there may be gaps in understanding between the governments, and the people of any two states due to differing cultures, and historical backgrounds. Moreover, the world is not an ideal place and liberalism as a concept has already failed. However, I am of the view that if the political will exists, the policy of Productive Engagement can deliver.
Let me explain the idea of productive engagement especially with the new Afghan government under the Taliban. The strategic location of Afghanistan that has attracted world powers over time would serve as an economic corridor for China, Russia, Central Asia, Iran, India, and Europe towards the Middle East and Africa. The CPEC can serve as an “economic bonanza” opening up new growth points for wealth generation in a recession prone global economy. The CPEC is a true face of my productive engagement diplomacy. While it is mutually beneficial for China and Pakistan, it can lift the entire region, especially Afghanistan. This is one reason why this phrase may be more viable than the usual diplomatic phrases. In the same vein, perhaps for the first time, an effort is made to find a regional solution to the Afghan problem, and Pakistan is leading the way. There is no other country, except Afghanistan, which is more affected due to continuing Afghan wars than Pakistan.
The new government of Afghanistan must not waste this opportunity of establishing a strong, stable, viable, and progressive state with an evolved concept of productive engagement with all stakeholders. This way, it would quickly get international recognition, and much-needed legitimacy to represent Afghanistan at world forums; the UN, OIC, SAARC (even if it is dormant due to India’s stubbornness), etc. To assist and support Afghanistan, Pakistan is making effort to galvanise regional support for a smooth transition of full administrative power to Taliban leadership in the coming weeks, perhaps following the policy of productive engagement.
The writer is the author of a book ‘Nuclear Deterrence and Conflict Management between India and Pakistan’. He is presently working as Director, Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS). This article was first published in Daily Times. He can be reached at cass.thinkers@gmail.com.
Image Source: Etfa Khurshid Mirza

Recent Articles
- Colombo’s Sorrow Read more
- Is Ukraine Becoming Europe’s Afghanistan? Read more
- Resurging Terrorism in Pakistan: What needs to be Done? Read more
- Social Media and Politics in Pakistan Read more
- Revisiting Counterterrorism Strategies of Pakistan Read more
- Initiatives to stimulate Pak-Afghan Bilateral Trade Read more
- The Durand Line Debate Read more
- Introducing ‘Realizm’ Read more
- OIC’s Council on Foreign Ministers Meeting & Pakistan’s Commitment towards Ending Humanitarian Crisis in Afghanistan Read more
- Rays of Hope in Kabul’s Winter Read more
- The Endgame Read more
- Spoilers cannot be Peace Builders Read more
- Disbanded Afghan Security Forces, Reinforcing IS-K and Regional Security Read more
- Taliban’s Rise is Changing the Security Landscape in Pakistan Read more
- Afghanistan deserves a Marshall Plan Plus Read more
- Déjà vu Moments Read more
- Effects of Ethnicity on Afghanistan’s Politics Read more
- Afghanistan and its Uncertainties Read more
- The Dilemma of Women in Afghanistan Read more
- Afghanistan 2.0:Development, Implications & Policy Options for Pakistan Read more
- The Taliban’s Ascendance in Afghanistan: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Afghanistan under Taliban: Beginning of a New Era? Read more
- Refugee Influx: Need to Learn from Past Experience Read more
- Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan: The Way Forward for Pakistan Read more
- Prospects of Pak-Iran Relations under President Raisi’s Government Read more
- The Need for Productive Engagement with New Afghan Government Read more
- How Corruption Aided Taliban’s Takeover Read more
- Countering Dubious Indo-US Designs in Afghanistan Read more
- Social Media: A Weapon of Mass Manipulation Read more
- Why is China Stepping up Geopolitics in Afghanistan? Read more
- The Economic Battle for Kabul Read more
- Victims of Wars in Afghanistan Read more
- The Fall of Kabul: A Public Value Perspective Read more
- Taliban here and Across the Khyber Read more
- Taliban Offensive and Abject Surrender of Afghan Forces Read more
- Seven Decades after Partition Read more
- The Afghan Imbroglio: A Pakistani Perspective Read more
- Hybrid Mannerism of the Terrorists and the State’s Response Read more
- Identifying Levels of Hybridity in War Read more
- The Second Wave of COVID-19 in Pakistan Read more
- While FATF Sleeps Read more
- پاکستان کی کورونا وائرس کے خلاف کامیابی کی اہم وجوہات Read more
- Iran joining the BRI: An Opportunity for Pakistan Read more
- Russia as a Resurgent Power - a Critical Analysis Read more
- Article 370: What Made PM Narendra Modi do it? Read more
- The Repulsive Face of Ultra-Nationalism Read more
- Pakistan’s Decisive Time to Act on its Weakening Kashmir Cause Read more
- End of Humanity! Read more
- Disputing the Disputed Status Read more
- The New Delhi Nazis Read more
- The implied truth Read more
- Modi, Media, Military a dangerous combination Read more
- The 'Reichstag Fire'of Pulwama Read more
- Pulwama, where was the world order? Read more
- The last sigh of Modi government Read more
- India's fake news calamity Read more
- War cost for India: half a trillion dollars Read more
- Sinking deeper into abyss Read more
- Decoding the Australian terrorist's manifesto Read more
- Time to Change our Approach Read more
- THE BLEEDING VALLEY Read more
- The cognitive dissonance of Indian Life Read more
- Has the FATF Failed? Read more
- PAF 'Ops Swift Retort' and effectiveness of Air Power Read more
- Why the fear? Read more
- Ijtamai Kifayat Sheari aur Usky Asraat Read more
- The Maturity of Debts and Governments Read more
- Indian Armed Forces – Myth and Reality Read more
- Time for a Public Finance Management Act Read more
- Implication of Abrogation of Article 370 Read more