Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistanis
Author Name: Dr Zia Ul Haque Shamsi 16 Jul 2021 Regional security/Region

Pakistan may have helped an incoming government in Afghanistan led by Taliban leader Mullah Omer with the help and support of other allies to avert a civil war in post-Soviet withdrawal in 1996.
However, Afghan Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistani soldiers, and therefore, Pakistan does not control Taliban’s political or military decision-making in any sense.
However, western propaganda against Pakistan, somehow seems to be gaining ground once again.
This time it is in an effort to malign Pakistan with not exercising enough control over Afghan Taliban, perhaps to hide their defeat.
This lack of clear understanding about Afghans is the core issue that every super power of the time has failed to subjugate Afghanistan. Afghans are not Indians who would wilfully submit to Babars, Ghauris, Suris, and the British.
Let me once again outline certain aspects of Afghanistan’s history to make people understand the genetic make-up of an Afghan, so that they may reconsider the allegations against Pakistan of not doing enough.
Afghanistan is strategically located but least developed due to its history riddled with wars, conflicts, and crises.
Afghanistan is a land of brave people, though ethnically diverse, who do not like to be ruled by outside powers. However, the same was not understood by at least three world powers at different times and each had to suffer humiliating defeat to retreat.
According to Thomas T. Hammond, Afghanistan was used as a battlefield between British and the Russians in the 19th century also.
Russians, in their quest to secure their southern borders and have access to warm waters, and British to extend its Indian sub-continent rule towards north and west.
However, soon the two world powers of the time realized that the hardships due to mountainous terrain and the unreliability of the local support, decided to keep Afghanistan as a buffer state between the two empires.
Without going too far back in the invasion history of Afghanistan by the Russians and the British, one can conclude that Afghanistan’s strategic location became a curse for the Afghan people since the time immemorial.
However, the Soviet’s invasion of 1979 is considered responsible for the present mess that Afghanistan is going through for the last over four decades. In the process, Afghanistan stood destroyed, and Soviet Union collapsed as a Union.
Afghanistan, after the Soviet’s withdrawal in 1989, went through an equally damaging civil war during which Mujahedeen formed their own government under the banner of ‘Taliban’ with Mullah Omer as their leader.
Only three countries: Saudi Arab, United Arab Emirates, and Pakistan recognized their rule in Kabul.
The painful decade of the 1990s ended with the tragedy of September 11, 2001, attacks on the US, a new war in Afghanistan began with US and its allies on the other side this time.
However, this time Pakistan was also a target because it was supporting the US. Pakistan suffered immensely in this new war in Afghanistan for supporting the US and its allies.
While US and NATO continued military operations in Afghanistan, there was at least one political leader in Pakistan, Imran Khan, who repeatedly warned that there is no military solution to Afghan problem and Afghans would never stop fighting unless the foreign forces leave Afghanistan.
However, he was termed as ‘Taliban Khan’ and declared as a sympathizer of Taliban.
Khan also opposed US drone strikes on Pakistan’s territory and led procession towards the FATA areas in protest to US drone operations. Khan was also critical of US actions in which Bin Laden was killed in Abbottabad.
He was of the view that US did not take Pakistan into confidence and violated its territorial integrity and sovereignty by sending its armed helicopters and marines inside Pakistan to eliminate Bin laden. Khan is now Prime Minster of Pakistan since August 2018.
Finally, US President Donald Trump wrote a letter to Pakistan’s PM Khan, requesting help to resolve Afghan crisis and assist US in exiting from Afghanistan without much trouble.
PM Khan assured President Trump of Pakistan’s fullest support in the process and managed to get all stakeholders on the negotiating table.
US-Taliban signed a landmark Agreement on February 29, 2020, in Doha-Qatar, and US agreed to withdraw all its troops from Afghanistan by May 1, 2021, however, new Biden Administration needed some time and promised to leave Afghanistan by September 11, 2021.
Afghanistan needs a break from wars, and conflicts. The world must understand that Afghans do not like to be ruled or take dictations from any outside entity, no matter who has done what for them.
Taliban spokesperson Suhail Shaheen in his interview on 12 July 2021, has categorically stated that Pakistan ‘cannot dictate to us,’ and Pakistan knows this more than any other country and that is one reason it has never sent an armed soldier or a fighter jet in the Afghan territory for military operations.
Therefore, it is important to understand Pakistan’s position that it does not have any leverage over Taliban, and cannot influence their politico-military decision-making at any level.
Dr Zia Ul Haque Shamsi is the author of the book ‘Nuclear Deterrence and Conflict Management Between India and Pakistan.’ This article was first published in Pakistan Observer. He is presently working as Director, Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS).
Photo Credit: Etfa Khurshid Mirza

Recent Articles
- Understanding the Politico-Economic Crises in South Asia Read more
- TTP’s Safe Haven in Afghanistan Read more
- Expanding Regional Connectivity between MESACA Read more
- Challenges to Regional Security Read more
- Will India let Pakistan’s Hopes of an Integrated Region & Abating Cold War II Materialise? Read more
- Saudi-Iran Rivalry: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Impact on Regional Security Read more
- China: A Helping Hand to Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Contributions towards Peace & Prosperity in Afghanistan Read more
- Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Regional Peace: An Opportunity for Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Strategic Relevance in South Asia Read more
- Chaos in Afghanistan: Economic Consequences for Pakistan Read more
- Battle of Perceptions Read more
- Peace in Afghanistan is a Choice! Read more
- Pakistan’s Afghan Dilemma Read more
- Strategic Pause Between the Nuclear Neighbours Read more
- Future of Region after US Exit from Afghanistan Read more
- “Why Would They Listen to Us When They are Sensing Victory?” Read more
- Taliban should Strive for a Hybrid Victory Read more
- Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistanis Read more
- Mapping the Terrorist Threat from Afghanistan Read more
- The Economic Dimensions of Pakistan-India Reengagement Read more
- Peace in the Subcontinent: Off-track Once Again Read more
- Afghanistan: Important Questions for the Future Read more
- Piecing Together the Afghan Puzzle Read more
- Post-US Exit Scenarios for Afghanistan and Regional Turmoil Read more
- Afghanistan and the Region Read more
- Proposed Peace Plan for South Asia Read more
- Terrorism: A Lingering Threat to South Asian Peace Read more
- Pakistan and India Rapprochement Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Pakistan’s Security Dilemma Read more
- Pakistan-India Peace Initiative Read more
- The United States: A Bystander, Balancer or Peace Broker in Future India-Pakistan Relations? Read more
- The US-Indo Pacific Shift: Opportunities for Pakistan Read more
- Revisiting Balakot Lessons Read more
- Operation Swift Retort and Misperceived Aggression Read more
- Lessons from Pulwama: A Prognosis of Future Military Conflicts in South Asia Read more
- Operation Swift Retort: Future Scenario Read more
- Revisiting February 27, 2019: PAF’s Befitting Reply to Indian Aggression Read more
- The Interplay of Hindutva Belligerence & Indian Economic Decline Read more
- Understanding Pulwama and Beyond Read more
- The Acts of Our Mercy Read more
- The Traps of Antiquity Read more
- Modi’s Hawkish Style of Leadership Read more
- On Strategic Competition between China and US Read more
- Modern Technologies and Future Warfare: Drawing Lessons from Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict Read more
- Impacts of Indian and Russian Coziness over US and Indian Defense Relations: The Case of S-400 Read more
- India-China border dispute has implications for Pakistan and region Read more
- An Argument on Sino-India Conflict Read more
- Ongoing India China Confrontation in the Himalayan Region Read more
- Irrationality To Realism: China-India Standoff Read more
- Sino-Indian Relations: A Tough Road Ahead Read more
- Indo-Nepal Tiff: Why are the Two Brothers Fighting? Read more
- How the Indian hardliners benefit Pakistan Read more
- India’s ‘Surgical Strike’ Doctrine: Implications for South Asian Strategic Stability Read more
- Pulwama/Balakot and The Evolving Role of Third Parties in India-Pakistan Crises Read more
- Is Populism Serving India’s Interest and that of the Region? Read more
- Pulwama: Revisiting the Lessons Read more
- US-Iran confrontation: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan Read more
- US-Iran Crisis: Is it the Beginning of the End? Read more
- A Dance of Blades Read more
- Emerging Trends in Asia Pacific: Japan-Australia Strategic Cooperation Read more
- The Changing Dynamics of Sino-India Relations – Options for Pakistan Read more
- Why Pakistan Cannot Afford a Saudi-Iran War Read more