Pulwama: Revisiting the Lessons
Author Name: Air Marshal Waseem Ud Din (Retd) 28 Feb 2020 Regional security/Region

The strategic environment in South Asia has its own characteristics, peculiarities, trends, and complexities. It has historically been in flux mainly because of the entrenched rivalry between two nuclear armed neighbors India and Pakistan. It has been further complicated by the interplay of extra-regional powers due to their geostrategic and geo-economic interests and more recently because of the efforts to contain China. The Indian regional and global aspirations, Afghanistan, terrorism, and host of internal religious, social, economic, political and cultural issues further compound the regional environment. Due to these complexities, the traditional concepts of strategic deterrence like those applicable in cold war don’t apply to the region. The Pulwama and the events that followed are the manifestation of the same notion.
The last year’s escalation between India and Pakistan, the causes, implications, and the lessons learnt have been discussed and debated at length. This article aims to highlight a few of the major conclusions and the lessons which could be drawn from the post-Pulwama crisis.
In February 2019, in retaliation to a terrorist incident in Pulwama, India misreading Pakistan’s response and deviating from its traditional doctrinal thinking resorted to conducting airstrike inside Pakistan, violating Pakistan’s territorial integrity, and then threatening to attack the targets across international border by missiles clearly showing her intentions to escalate. Though the attack was a clear violation of article 2 (4) of UN Charter; an act of war, it was termed as non-military strike by India to shape international opinion and to create a response dilemma for Pakistan.
The hyper and arrogant Indian media then created a war hysteria through an unprecedented fake news campaign, deceiving Indian public to a false sense of victory and projecting Pakistan as the actual instigator of aggression. As expected, the international community condemned the Pulwama incident and turned a blind eye towards the Indian aggression.
Displaying its resolve to retaliate, Pakistan Air Force struck back by projecting its ability to engage targets across LOC, shooting down a MiG 21 and a SU 30, and creating a scenario of loss of situational awareness where IAF shot down its own helicopter. The carefully planned, calibrated and resolute response by Pakistan Air Force which seriously challenged the Indian conventional myth and escalation dominance, restored the red-lines and equilibrium within 30 hours, forcing India to brandish its nuclear weapons.
That was when the international community woke up to the seriousness of the situation and rushed to deescalate. Despite the serious efforts by Pakistan to deescalate, like repatriation of the downed pilot and other diplomatic moves, India continued with its misadventures this time in sea. An Indian submarine was detected and localized in Pakistan’s maritime zone on 4th March, 2019.
The crisis reestablished the age-old efficacy of using air as the primary policy tool to achieve both national and military objectives expeditiously. However, the employment of air power during the crisis brought to fore that air will have strategic effects once employed like PAF. It definitely restored the deterrence and strategic stability. However, once unprofessionally employed without proper planning like IAF, it could yield negative effects. Indian employment of air force for supposedly a punitive surgical strike, against a nuclear armed, potent country having the resolve to respond, was definitely not a wise idea, rather, a dangerous precedent. Using the air power for political objectives and assuming that Pakistan will not respond was misperceived by Indian leadership.
The Indian threat of using surface-to-surface missiles against Pakistan’s military targets and the reported patrol by Indian submarines was fraught with grave implications. With no clearly separated conventional and nuclear delivery systems, there would always be chances of miscalculation, when employing dual-use delivery systems in such a scenario. Had Pakistan resorted to a similar move, it would have definitely been termed as an irresponsible state by the international community.
India for a long time, has been trying to explore space for a conventional conflict under a nuclear overhang or for a ‘punitive’ measure against Pakistan to assert its hegemony. First, it was cold start doctrine, which was subsequently modified into Proactive Operations strategy. The failure to operationalize these war fighting concepts during various crises led India to explore various options.
India’s post-Pulwama air action points towards new thinking of using airpower as instrument of choice to use it at any level and scale to carve notion of moral and psychological ascendency. Without deploying land forces, the air-centric approach using the technology, flexibility and responsiveness of airpower to achieve the desired effects in political domain, indicates a new trend. Pakistan’s response that caused significant damage to India’s reputation and prestige of a credible military power in the region, is likely to deter India from contemplating similar military measures in the future. However, the doctrinal shift in Indian military application coupled with its acquisition of ballistic missile defense, supersonic cruise missiles and its ambitious military space program warrant a relook at our war fighting doctrine and capabilities.
The most important of the conclusions which has come to fore is the significance of opposing perceptions in the region, which need to be clearly understood by the world for creating an enduring stability in the region. The world also need to understand that the biggest source of instability in the region is the preferential treatment meted out to India, which not only is resulting in emboldening its military might, but is also incentivizing her to act at will disregarding the international norms.
This article is written by Air Marshal Waseem ud din (Retd). He is working as Director National Security Outlook and Academic Coord at Centre for Aerospace and Security Studies. This article was first published in The News. He can be reached at cass.thinkers@gmail.com
Recent Articles
- Saudi-Iran Rapprochement: Vital for Middle East’s Security Read more
- Understanding the Politico-Economic Crises in South Asia Read more
- TTP’s Safe Haven in Afghanistan Read more
- Expanding Regional Connectivity between MESACA Read more
- Challenges to Regional Security Read more
- Will India let Pakistan’s Hopes of an Integrated Region & Abating Cold War II Materialise? Read more
- Saudi-Iran Rivalry: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Impact on Regional Security Read more
- China: A Helping Hand to Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Contributions towards Peace & Prosperity in Afghanistan Read more
- Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Regional Peace: An Opportunity for Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Strategic Relevance in South Asia Read more
- Chaos in Afghanistan: Economic Consequences for Pakistan Read more
- Battle of Perceptions Read more
- Peace in Afghanistan is a Choice! Read more
- Pakistan’s Afghan Dilemma Read more
- Strategic Pause Between the Nuclear Neighbours Read more
- Future of Region after US Exit from Afghanistan Read more
- “Why Would They Listen to Us When They are Sensing Victory?” Read more
- Taliban should Strive for a Hybrid Victory Read more
- Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistanis Read more
- Mapping the Terrorist Threat from Afghanistan Read more
- The Economic Dimensions of Pakistan-India Reengagement Read more
- Peace in the Subcontinent: Off-track Once Again Read more
- Afghanistan: Important Questions for the Future Read more
- Piecing Together the Afghan Puzzle Read more
- Post-US Exit Scenarios for Afghanistan and Regional Turmoil Read more
- Afghanistan and the Region Read more
- Proposed Peace Plan for South Asia Read more
- Terrorism: A Lingering Threat to South Asian Peace Read more
- Pakistan and India Rapprochement Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Pakistan’s Security Dilemma Read more
- Pakistan-India Peace Initiative Read more
- The United States: A Bystander, Balancer or Peace Broker in Future India-Pakistan Relations? Read more
- The US-Indo Pacific Shift: Opportunities for Pakistan Read more
- Revisiting Balakot Lessons Read more
- Operation Swift Retort and Misperceived Aggression Read more
- Lessons from Pulwama: A Prognosis of Future Military Conflicts in South Asia Read more
- Operation Swift Retort: Future Scenario Read more
- Revisiting February 27, 2019: PAF’s Befitting Reply to Indian Aggression Read more
- The Interplay of Hindutva Belligerence & Indian Economic Decline Read more
- Understanding Pulwama and Beyond Read more
- The Acts of Our Mercy Read more
- The Traps of Antiquity Read more
- Modi’s Hawkish Style of Leadership Read more
- On Strategic Competition between China and US Read more
- Modern Technologies and Future Warfare: Drawing Lessons from Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict Read more
- Impacts of Indian and Russian Coziness over US and Indian Defense Relations: The Case of S-400 Read more
- India-China border dispute has implications for Pakistan and region Read more
- An Argument on Sino-India Conflict Read more
- Ongoing India China Confrontation in the Himalayan Region Read more
- Irrationality To Realism: China-India Standoff Read more
- Sino-Indian Relations: A Tough Road Ahead Read more
- Indo-Nepal Tiff: Why are the Two Brothers Fighting? Read more
- How the Indian hardliners benefit Pakistan Read more
- India’s ‘Surgical Strike’ Doctrine: Implications for South Asian Strategic Stability Read more
- Pulwama/Balakot and The Evolving Role of Third Parties in India-Pakistan Crises Read more
- Is Populism Serving India’s Interest and that of the Region? Read more
- Pulwama: Revisiting the Lessons Read more
- US-Iran confrontation: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan Read more
- US-Iran Crisis: Is it the Beginning of the End? Read more
- A Dance of Blades Read more
- Emerging Trends in Asia Pacific: Japan-Australia Strategic Cooperation Read more
- The Changing Dynamics of Sino-India Relations – Options for Pakistan Read more
- Why Pakistan Cannot Afford a Saudi-Iran War Read more