Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan
Author Name: Zuhaib Anwar 28 Jan 2020 Regional security/Region

The long-awaited results of presidential elections in Afghanistan were announced on 22 December. Amidst allegations of rigging, President Ashraf Ghani is set to lead Afghanistan for a second term. While on the US-Taliban negotiations front, the US Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation has stated that the talks are at an important stage. Chances are that a deal will be finalized in the days to come, as Taliban have agreed to a temporary ceasefire, during which a deal is expected to be signed. But for a long-lasting peace in Afghanistan, the importance of intra-Afghan dialogue cannot be overestimated. The dialogue will begin within two weeks of signing of the US-Taliban agreement, and it is during this interaction that the future of Afghanistan would be decided. The form of government and a power-sharing formula among various factions will come under discussion during negotiations.
A similar situation arose in Afghanistan shortly after the disintegration of the Soviet Union in 1991, when the communist government led by President Muhammad Najibullah was removed from power. Efforts were made to form a unity government that would pave the way for a future democratic setup in Afghanistan. The two main factions that competed for the top positions in the unity government included the Jamiat-e-Islami, a predominantly Tajik group led by Burhanuddin Rabbani and Ahmed Shah Masood, and the Hezb-e-Islami, composed largely of Pashtuns led by Gulbuddin Hekmatyar.
A deal facilitated by the United Nations, the United States, and Pakistan was signed in Peshawar on 24 April 1992, known as the Peshawar Accord. Through this Accord, various government positions were divided between different factions of Mujahideen. However, Hekmatyar, who was to serve as prime minister, refused to be part of the unity government as he was unwilling to share power with Ahmad Shah Masood as the defence minister. The very next week, Kabul was shelled by Hekmatyar’s forces using heavy artillery, and Afghanistan plunged into civil war. The attitudinal inflexibility on part of the warlords and their unwillingness to sit together has resulted in interminable and severe hardships for the people of Afghanistan.
The current situation in Afghanistan resembles that of 1992. The foreign forces will withdraw, and intra-Afghan dialogue will begin, but it will not be easy for the factions operating in Afghanistan to agree to a power-sharing arrangement. Intensive international diplomatic efforts would be required to convince all the parties to find consensus on various important issues. The points in question that would require resolution during the negotiations include: amendment to the current constitution or adopting a new one as Taliban do not accept the constitution of Afghanistan in its current form, safeguarding of women's rights that would require guarantees from Taliban as their track record is not good in this context, integration of fighters into the society as every warlord maintains a sizeable militia, and status of the current government and parliament as both came to office through a popular vote. The parliamentary elections were held on 20 October 2018 and the parliament was inaugurated on 26 April 2019; whereas the preliminary results of the presidential elections held on 28 September 2019 were announced by the Election Commission on 27 October 2019, which means that before the start of an intra-Afghan dialogue, a new government will be in place, but will the incumbent president vacate his post to pave way for a unity government? If history is repeated, and sufficient flexibility isn’t shown by all parties, things are not likely to move forward in a positive direction. In this regard, the people of Afghanistan would have to play a crucial role in exerting pressure on the Afghan leadership to create consensus amongst them and let Afghanistan move forward from its violent past. The international community would also have to exert influence over various groups to come to the negotiating table and be ready to show greater flexibility.
For a lasting peace and to give the disillusioned people of Afghanistan relief from the misery they have been going through for so long, the leadership will have to set aside their individual agendas and work diligently for a peaceful and better future of Afghanistan, or else, history will repeat itself and Afghanistan will drift back into a civil war and ultimately the people of Afghanistan will continue to suffer.
Zuhaib Anwar works as a Researcher at Centre for Aerospace and Security Studies (CASS). This article was first published in Daily NHT newspaper. He can be reached at cass.thinkers@gmail.com.
Recent Articles
- Saudi-Iran Rapprochement: Vital for Middle East’s Security Read more
- Understanding the Politico-Economic Crises in South Asia Read more
- TTP’s Safe Haven in Afghanistan Read more
- Expanding Regional Connectivity between MESACA Read more
- Challenges to Regional Security Read more
- Will India let Pakistan’s Hopes of an Integrated Region & Abating Cold War II Materialise? Read more
- Saudi-Iran Rivalry: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Impact on Regional Security Read more
- China: A Helping Hand to Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Contributions towards Peace & Prosperity in Afghanistan Read more
- Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Regional Peace: An Opportunity for Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Strategic Relevance in South Asia Read more
- Chaos in Afghanistan: Economic Consequences for Pakistan Read more
- Battle of Perceptions Read more
- Peace in Afghanistan is a Choice! Read more
- Pakistan’s Afghan Dilemma Read more
- Strategic Pause Between the Nuclear Neighbours Read more
- Future of Region after US Exit from Afghanistan Read more
- “Why Would They Listen to Us When They are Sensing Victory?” Read more
- Taliban should Strive for a Hybrid Victory Read more
- Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistanis Read more
- Mapping the Terrorist Threat from Afghanistan Read more
- The Economic Dimensions of Pakistan-India Reengagement Read more
- Peace in the Subcontinent: Off-track Once Again Read more
- Afghanistan: Important Questions for the Future Read more
- Piecing Together the Afghan Puzzle Read more
- Post-US Exit Scenarios for Afghanistan and Regional Turmoil Read more
- Afghanistan and the Region Read more
- Proposed Peace Plan for South Asia Read more
- Terrorism: A Lingering Threat to South Asian Peace Read more
- Pakistan and India Rapprochement Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Pakistan’s Security Dilemma Read more
- Pakistan-India Peace Initiative Read more
- The United States: A Bystander, Balancer or Peace Broker in Future India-Pakistan Relations? Read more
- The US-Indo Pacific Shift: Opportunities for Pakistan Read more
- Revisiting Balakot Lessons Read more
- Operation Swift Retort and Misperceived Aggression Read more
- Lessons from Pulwama: A Prognosis of Future Military Conflicts in South Asia Read more
- Operation Swift Retort: Future Scenario Read more
- Revisiting February 27, 2019: PAF’s Befitting Reply to Indian Aggression Read more
- The Interplay of Hindutva Belligerence & Indian Economic Decline Read more
- Understanding Pulwama and Beyond Read more
- The Acts of Our Mercy Read more
- The Traps of Antiquity Read more
- Modi’s Hawkish Style of Leadership Read more
- On Strategic Competition between China and US Read more
- Modern Technologies and Future Warfare: Drawing Lessons from Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict Read more
- Impacts of Indian and Russian Coziness over US and Indian Defense Relations: The Case of S-400 Read more
- India-China border dispute has implications for Pakistan and region Read more
- An Argument on Sino-India Conflict Read more
- Ongoing India China Confrontation in the Himalayan Region Read more
- Irrationality To Realism: China-India Standoff Read more
- Sino-Indian Relations: A Tough Road Ahead Read more
- Indo-Nepal Tiff: Why are the Two Brothers Fighting? Read more
- How the Indian hardliners benefit Pakistan Read more
- India’s ‘Surgical Strike’ Doctrine: Implications for South Asian Strategic Stability Read more
- Pulwama/Balakot and The Evolving Role of Third Parties in India-Pakistan Crises Read more
- Is Populism Serving India’s Interest and that of the Region? Read more
- Pulwama: Revisiting the Lessons Read more
- US-Iran confrontation: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan Read more
- US-Iran Crisis: Is it the Beginning of the End? Read more
- A Dance of Blades Read more
- Emerging Trends in Asia Pacific: Japan-Australia Strategic Cooperation Read more
- The Changing Dynamics of Sino-India Relations – Options for Pakistan Read more
- Why Pakistan Cannot Afford a Saudi-Iran War Read more