Lessons from Pulwama: A Prognosis of Future Military Conflicts in South Asia
Author Name: Abdullah Rehman Butt 27 Feb 2021 Regional security/Region

The South Asian strategic landscape is mainly characterized by the fierce animosity between the two nuclear-armed nations, India and Pakistan. The strategic calculus of the region became even more complex with the introduction of nuclear weapons in the region. Though in Pakistan’s perspective, there is no space for a war between India and Pakistan because of their deterrence relationship based on nuclear weapons, however, India always tries to create a window for limited military conflict under a nuclear overhang. Consequently, the region has witnessed some intense military crises (Kargil crisis, military deployments in 2001 and 2008, Pulwama) which brought both states to the brink of war.
The most recent military crisis in South Asia arises on 26 February 2019 when the Indian Air Force jets violated the International border of Pakistan and conducted a so-called airstrike at Balakot in response to a suicide bombing that happened on 14 February 2019 in Indian Occupied Kashmir. Pakistan Air Force, in its response named Operation Swift Retort, successfully restored the conventional thresholds by targeting Indian military installations in Indian Occupied Kashmir and shot down two IAF's fighter jets on 27 February 2019. PAF’s carefully planned response not only projected its capability to engage targets across the LOC but also showcased its resolve to retaliate against every kind of aggression by India.
A careful analysis of the Pulwama crisis hints towards the emergence of new precedents in the pattern of military conflicts in South Asia. India responded to a sub-conventional false flag activity in the conventional domain in an unprecedented manner. For the first time, the international border was crossed by Indian Air Force since 1971, and for the first time, India used its air force to achieve political objectives. For the first time, India posed a threat of conventional missile strike in Pakistan, which could lead to misperceptions and further compounded the problems for crisis stability in the region.
The duration of the crisis remained short, while the tensions were high that put a lot of pressure on the military leadership of both the countries. Indian failed strike also put a question mark on the quality of leadership of Indian armed force. First of all, the Balakot strike was an abysmally planned strike that couldn’t yield their desired results. Secondly, they did not factor in the capability and resolve to respond by the Pakistan Air Force. Later on, the Indian military leadership even lost its credibility by making false claims about the damages they had inflicted and the loss of their Su-30 MKI in front of their nation. On the other hand, PAF vividly demonstrated its capability and responsibility towards national defense and the stability of the region and showed restraints in its counter strike mission, reaffirming its role as a potent as well as a responsible air force in the region. Hence, the conventional deterrence thresholds of Pakistan were tested at a new level against a conventionally superior adversary.
The pattern of future military conflicts in South Asia can be predicted in light of the lessons learned from the Balakot crisis and the recent developments in the military domain in the region. Firstly, India can again go for any misadventure in the name of punishing Pakistan for any sub conventional activity in India or in IOJK in order to achieve its domestic political objectives or to divert the attention of its masses from poor economic performance and other internal vulnerabilities. Secondly, The future conflicts would remain limited and the duration of the conflict would be short, in a result of which, the role of air power in any future military crises would be crucial because of its swift and decisive operational effects. Thirdly, there would be comparatively reduced reliance on the land forces and their mobilization in any future conflict in South Asia because of the higher cost and time involved. Fourthly, there would be an increased role of cyber and space capabilities in future conflicts and the concept of cross domain deterrence would be the key to minimize the chance of any conflict escalation. Lastly, Indian military modernization with the help of its western allies is pushing the region into an endless arms race that is negatively affecting the strategic stability of the region. India's acquisition of hypersonic weapons, ballistic missile defense system, precision strike capability, and anti-satellite weapons would put India in a strategically advantageous position, and it might think of a preemptive counter-force strike against Pakistan. This would not only be detrimental to the strategic stability of the region but the first strike stability would also increasingly come under stress in any future military conflict.
India’s regional hegemonic ambitions, its military modernization, and its strategic partnership with the US aimed at containing China are hugely tilting the strategic balance of the South Asian region into India’s favor. Indian access to information and modern military equipment, under various agreements with the western powers, would provide India with a decisive edge in any future military conflict with Pakistan. Despite its fragile economic conditions, Pakistan will have to chalk out a comprehensive strategy to offset Indian conventional superiority in order to keep its deterrence relationship effective with India. Pakistan also needs to consolidate its conventional capabilities to address growing conventional asymmetry vis-à-vis India and to befittingly respond to any future conventional threat. Moreover, Pakistan should also focus on the development of its cyber and space capabilities to meet its future warfare needs including advanced ISR and Network-Centric capabilities. Cooperation with friendly countries like China and Turkey would be the key in this regard.
Abdullah Rehman Butt is a researcher at the Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS). The article was first published in REGIONAL TIMES. He can be reached at cass.thinkers@gmail.com

Recent Articles
- Saudi-Iran Rapprochement: Vital for Middle East’s Security Read more
- Understanding the Politico-Economic Crises in South Asia Read more
- TTP’s Safe Haven in Afghanistan Read more
- Expanding Regional Connectivity between MESACA Read more
- Challenges to Regional Security Read more
- Will India let Pakistan’s Hopes of an Integrated Region & Abating Cold War II Materialise? Read more
- Saudi-Iran Rivalry: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Impact on Regional Security Read more
- China: A Helping Hand to Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Contributions towards Peace & Prosperity in Afghanistan Read more
- Shanghai Cooperation Organization and Regional Peace: An Opportunity for Afghanistan Read more
- Pakistan’s Strategic Relevance in South Asia Read more
- Chaos in Afghanistan: Economic Consequences for Pakistan Read more
- Battle of Perceptions Read more
- Peace in Afghanistan is a Choice! Read more
- Pakistan’s Afghan Dilemma Read more
- Strategic Pause Between the Nuclear Neighbours Read more
- Future of Region after US Exit from Afghanistan Read more
- “Why Would They Listen to Us When They are Sensing Victory?” Read more
- Taliban should Strive for a Hybrid Victory Read more
- Taliban are Afghans only and not Pakistanis Read more
- Mapping the Terrorist Threat from Afghanistan Read more
- The Economic Dimensions of Pakistan-India Reengagement Read more
- Peace in the Subcontinent: Off-track Once Again Read more
- Afghanistan: Important Questions for the Future Read more
- Piecing Together the Afghan Puzzle Read more
- Post-US Exit Scenarios for Afghanistan and Regional Turmoil Read more
- Afghanistan and the Region Read more
- Proposed Peace Plan for South Asia Read more
- Terrorism: A Lingering Threat to South Asian Peace Read more
- Pakistan and India Rapprochement Read more
- Indo-US Strategic Partnership: Pakistan’s Security Dilemma Read more
- Pakistan-India Peace Initiative Read more
- The United States: A Bystander, Balancer or Peace Broker in Future India-Pakistan Relations? Read more
- The US-Indo Pacific Shift: Opportunities for Pakistan Read more
- Revisiting Balakot Lessons Read more
- Operation Swift Retort and Misperceived Aggression Read more
- Lessons from Pulwama: A Prognosis of Future Military Conflicts in South Asia Read more
- Operation Swift Retort: Future Scenario Read more
- Revisiting February 27, 2019: PAF’s Befitting Reply to Indian Aggression Read more
- The Interplay of Hindutva Belligerence & Indian Economic Decline Read more
- Understanding Pulwama and Beyond Read more
- The Acts of Our Mercy Read more
- The Traps of Antiquity Read more
- Modi’s Hawkish Style of Leadership Read more
- On Strategic Competition between China and US Read more
- Modern Technologies and Future Warfare: Drawing Lessons from Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict Read more
- Impacts of Indian and Russian Coziness over US and Indian Defense Relations: The Case of S-400 Read more
- India-China border dispute has implications for Pakistan and region Read more
- An Argument on Sino-India Conflict Read more
- Ongoing India China Confrontation in the Himalayan Region Read more
- Irrationality To Realism: China-India Standoff Read more
- Sino-Indian Relations: A Tough Road Ahead Read more
- Indo-Nepal Tiff: Why are the Two Brothers Fighting? Read more
- How the Indian hardliners benefit Pakistan Read more
- India’s ‘Surgical Strike’ Doctrine: Implications for South Asian Strategic Stability Read more
- Pulwama/Balakot and The Evolving Role of Third Parties in India-Pakistan Crises Read more
- Is Populism Serving India’s Interest and that of the Region? Read more
- Pulwama: Revisiting the Lessons Read more
- US-Iran confrontation: Implications for Pakistan Read more
- Prospects for Peace in Afghanistan Read more
- US-Iran Crisis: Is it the Beginning of the End? Read more
- A Dance of Blades Read more
- Emerging Trends in Asia Pacific: Japan-Australia Strategic Cooperation Read more
- The Changing Dynamics of Sino-India Relations – Options for Pakistan Read more
- Why Pakistan Cannot Afford a Saudi-Iran War Read more