Economics and the Revisionist Mind
Author Name: Dr. Usman Chohan 24 Jan 2020 International Economy

The revisionist mind is one that fails to reconcile with prevailing narratives, facts, or experiences. Whether in the outcomes of historical battles or the manipulation of undesirable economic figures, the revisionist mind goes about reworking all aspects that do not concede to its interpretations.
The current government of Republic of India, ruled by ideologues of the Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP), seeks to not simply reinterpret history but also revise its precepts entirely. It similarly discards the rigor of economic statistics to try and fool both the domestic public and investors abroad.
Regarding history, the BJP’s strategy is two-fold. First, it highlights exclusively the contributions of those who cohere with a Hindu Rashtra. Second, it minimises the contributions of any groups they deem “foreign” and re-portray their presence as largely negative and undesirable.
Regarding economics, the BJP’s strategy is also two-fold. First, the BJP unremittingly manipulates and exaggerates the national economic growth statistics of India. What many central bankers and economic analysts, both within and beyond India, have found to be the case is that the BJP has been over-stating its GDP statistics by more than 3 percentage points for countless successive quarters.
In other words, instead of the high and mighty 7 per cent GDP growth they touted to the world, they were growing at nothing more than 4 per cent. This is a much bleaker reality that the BJP has sought to conceal through manipulation. At the very least, it is nothing remarkable and certainly not worth the constant harping of a self-professed “economic tiger.”
Second, once the illusion of their growth became untenable, the BJP tried to ascribe the blame for this to the Congress party, and even to Pakistan. Recently, the myth of the juggernaut economy appeared to unravel as unemployment figures hit a historic high (6.1%, well above the historical mean of 3%). But further still, industrial output has been in decline, inflation has risen, and even runs on some of the Indian banks seem imminent.
The irredentist element in this is that the BJP shifts the blame to everyone but themselves, and insists to its increasingly radicalised base that “traitors” and “foreigners” have left them unredeemed. If these [Muslim] foreigners were to disappear, then clearly the economy would soar. If the BJP could have its way with everything, then only would India return to glory.
Invariably, they despise the reality that they shall not attain their glorious destiny of a five trillion dollar economy in the time frame that they had been touting. Congress is squarely to blame for this, not to mention its Pakistani benefactors, and the time has come for the thorns in their side to be eradicated.
What must be gleaned from economic example is that the nature of the revisionist mind is such that it permeates all walks of life and must be warned against not just in the spheres of history, politics, violence, and geography but must be guarded against and unveiled in every facet of totalitarian projects.
Economics is but one lens, yet the BJP revises history in the same way that it revises its economic statistics. It manipulates historical grievances (real or imagined); the same way that it manipulates economic data. In the same way that it shifts the blame for historical setbacks to foreigners, it shifts the blame for its economic setbacks on just about anyone but themselves.
But as with its exaggerated historical edits, its economic figures are raising eyebrows. Foreign investors are scrambling for the door and now refuse to buy the BJP’s line on sugar-coated figures. The Indian public itself is no longer persuaded by Modi’s numbers – a different reality of economic hardship stares them in the face.
This is an instructive lesson in the breadth of the revisionist mind. No history is a correct history until it reflects their vision of what is right. No economics is correct economics until it portrays them in the best possible light.
–The writer is the Director for Economics and National Affairs at the Centre for Aerospace and Security Studies (CASS). He can be reached at cass.thinkers@gmail.com. This article was first published in The Nation newspaper https://nation.com.pk/E-Paper/islamabad/2020-01-23/page-14/detail-4.
Recent Articles
- Stagflation Read more
- The Pivotal Islamic Development Bank Read more
- The Russo-Ukrainian Conflict: An Economics Research Agenda Read more
- Their Map, Our Territory Read more
- The Return of Keynesianism? Exploring Path Dependency and Ideational Change in Post-Covid Fiscal Policy Read more
- The Currency Switch Read more
- The BRICs: 20 Years Later Read more
- The Ripple Effects of Increasing Oil Prices Read more
- The Third Stage of Modern China Read more
- Evolving Geo-economic Landscape: Opportunity for Deeper Economic Ties between Iran and Pakistan Read more
- The Space Silk Road (SSR): An Avenue for China-Pakistan Space Cooperation Read more
- A Confession about FATF Read more
- A Sober Look at the FATF Read more
- Interplay of Shock Therapy & Authoritarianism Read more
- The Miracle in Bengal Read more
- Inequality & Insecurity: An Unorthodox Correlation Read more
- Economic Security in a World Context Read more
- On Central Bank Independence Read more
- BRI and the QUAD Plus: Emerging Avenues for Regional Development Read more
- The Big Bazooka Read more
- China’s Economy: Plebeians and Billionaires Read more
- Money Laundering and Jurisprudence Read more
- Economic Diplomacy: A Review Read more
- Reprieve and Mercy Debt Relief for the Developing World during Coronavirus Read more
- The Interplay of Free Speech & Economic Growth Read more
- IMF & Pakistan’s Inflationary Conundrum Read more
- COVID-19 & the Global Supply Chains Read more
- The Interplay of Economics & Defence Read more
- IMF: Austerity & Security Read more
- New Laws and the FATF Read more
- Beware the Vultures Read more
- The Parallel Universe of Stock Markets Read more
- US-China COVID(RY) and the Samson Option! Read more
- Coronavirus and Modern Monetary Theory Read more
- Modern Monetary Theory (MMT): A General Introduction Read more
- Corona-Capitalism Read more
- Karmic justice and economics Read more
- The trouble with economics Read more
- Economics and the Revisionist Mind Read more
- The tax whistleblowers Read more
- The Country of the Future Read more
- F as in IMF Read more
- Watchdog or Lapdog? Read more
- Economic Vandalism in our time Read more